The Value of Feedback for Teaching and Learning

In higher education, feedback is more than just guidance it is a catalyst for growth. For students, it illuminates the path to deeper understanding and improved learning outcomes. For lecturers, it offers insights that inspire more effective and responsive teaching practices. This newsletter explores how both students and lecturers perceive feedback, drawing on insights from recent studies and articles. By highlighting the gap between current understanding and desired performance, feedback empowers learners and educators alike to reach their full potential.

Effective feedback should address three key questions: Where am I going?  (What are the goals?), How am I going? (What progress is being made?), and  Where to next? (What actions are needed to improve?). These correspond to feed up, feedback, and feed forward, respectively.

Feedback operates at different levels, including task performance, understanding processes, regulatory or metacognitive processes, and personal levels. It is crucial to provide feedback at the appropriate level to effectively reduce the gap between current understanding and desired goals. Properly targeted feedback can significantly enhance learning outcomes by guiding students on their progress and the steps needed to achieve their goals.

In addition, feedback is most effective when it is timely, specific, and constructive. It should not only inform students about areas for improvement but also make them feel supported, encouraged, and motivated to grow. Clear guidance on how to enhance performance in future assessments helps students take concrete steps toward success. Actively engaging with feedback, asking questions for clarification, and reflecting on one’s work are essential practices that transform feedback from a simple evaluation into a tool for meaningful learning. When students and lecturers embrace these strategies, they create a collaborative and dynamic learning environment where growth is continuous, teaching is refined, and both student outcomes and academic experiences are significantly enhanced.

Feedback from the Lecturer’s Perspective

Lecturers play a pivotal role in the feedback process. Effective feedback from lecturers can significantly impact students’ learning experiences and outcomes.

  1. Traditional vs. Modern Feedback Approaches
    Many lecturers continue to use traditional forms of feedback, which often fail to meet students’ needs for timely and actionable insights. Modern feedback techniques, such as e-feedback, audio feedback, and peer dialogue, are proving to be more effective.

  2. Quality of Information
    Providing high-quality information is essential. Lecturers should aim to give specific, constructive feedback that students can use to improve their performance. Feedback should not only highlight areas of improvement but also recognize students’ strengths to encourage a positive learning environment.

  3. Motivational Feedback
    Feedback should inspire students to achieve better results. Positive reinforcement and constructive criticism help students stay motivated and engaged with their studies. It is important for lecturers to balance critical feedback with encouragement to foster a supportive learning atmosphere.

Feedback from the Student’s Perspective

Students view feedback as a crucial element of their learning process. Effective feedback helps them understand their progress and areas needing improvement.

  1. Understanding Performance Goals
    Students need to clearly understand the performance goals and criteria set by their lecturers. This understanding helps them align their efforts with the expected outcomes. When feedback is aligned with these goals, it becomes a powerful tool for self-assessment and improvement.

  2. Timeliness and Relevance
    One of the common complaints among students is the lack of timely feedback. Feedback should be provided promptly to allow students to apply the insights to their subsequent tasks. Delays in feedback can diminish its effectiveness and students’ ability to use it constructively.

  3. Feedback as a Dialogue
    Students benefit from viewing feedback as a dialogue rather than a one-way communication. Opportunities for discussions about feedback can enhance understanding and application. Peer dialogue and interactive feedback sessions can make the feedback process more dynamic and beneficial.

  4. Self-Regulation and Reflection
    Encouraging students to engage in self-assessment and reflection is crucial. Feedback should help students develop their ability to self-regulate and reflect on their learning processes. This approach not only improves their current performance but also fosters lifelong learning skills.

Feedback is a powerful tool in the higher education landscape, benefiting both students and lecturers. By adopting modern feedback techniques, ensuring the quality and timeliness of feedback, and fostering an interactive dialogue, higher education institutions can enhance the overall learning experience.

It is imperative for lecturers to rethink traditional feedback methods and embrace more effective, technology-based approaches to meet the evolving needs of students.

References

Assessment and feedback: A guide for UCL students. Retrieved from assessment-feedback-guide.pdf.

Molina-Moreira, A. A., Velásquez-Orellana, O. J., Zambrano-Murillo, D. J., & Zambrano-Villamil, M. E. (2023). Importance of Feedback in the Student Evaluation Process. International Journal of Social Sciences, 6(3), 168-172. https://doi.org/10.21744/ijss.v6n3.2176

Mamoon-Al-Bashir, M., Kabir, M. R., & Rahman, I. (2016). The Value and Effectiveness of Feedback in Improving Students’ Learning and Professionalizing Teaching in Higher Education. Journal of Education and Practice, Vol.7, No.16, 2016. Retrieved from EJ1105282.pdf